FAQ

Questions, answered.

Can't find what you need? Message us directly.

Consigning
What do you accept?

Graded and raw sports cards valued at $250 and up, modern and vintage. We take slabs from PSA, BGS, SGC, and CGC, and raw cards too. If a raw card would be worth more graded, we'll talk through grading options with you.

Is there a minimum?

$250 per card.

How do I get my card to you?

Ship it with a tracked label, or drop it off in Philadelphia by appointment. For cards of $10,000+, we send you a prepaid label.

What happens when my card arrives?

We open the package on continuous video, verify the cert with the grader, inspect the slab, and send you condition photos within 1 business day of receipt.

Selling
Where will my card sell?

On eBay, through the Liberty Collect store. eBay has no buyer's premium, so bidders pay the hammer price.

Can I set a reserve?

Yes. You can choose an auction with a reserve, an auction with your start price, or Buy It Now / Best Offer. If eBay charges a reserve fee, we pass it through at cost.

How fast will it be listed?

Within 3 business days of intake. If we miss that, we take 1 point off our commission.

Is my card authenticated when it sells?

Eligible cards of $200 and up sold on eBay go through eBay's Authenticity Guarantee. An independent authenticator checks the card before it reaches the buyer, which gives bidders confidence.

Does Liberty Collect ever bid on consigned cards?

No. Liberty Collect and its staff never bid on consigned lots. If we want to buy a card outright, we make a disclosed offer in writing.

Fees & payment
What are your fees?

You keep 80% to 95% depending on the final sale price, and Founding Consignors keep up to 96%. eBay's fees, photography, and shipping to the buyer are included. See the Fees page for the full schedule.

When do I get paid?

By ACH or wire, within 3 business days of eBay releasing the funds, with an itemized statement.

What if my card doesn't sell?

We relist it once for free. After that we'll talk through pricing, or return the card. You only pay return shipping.

Can I pull my card after it's listed?

Yes. There's a withdrawal fee of 5% of the reserve or the agreed estimate.

Do you offer cash advances?

Not at launch. Follow @ONEbyLiberty for updates.

Still have a question?

Ask Ryan directly. You'll get an answer from a person.

Contact us